In this special two-part blog post from two creative digital agencies, Sarah Morris, Marketing Manager at Sequence, makes the case for arts organisations to outsource their social media management, while Tom Beardshaw, Partner at Native HQ, says organisations can only retain their voice by keeping social media in-house.
Photo used under Creative Commons from marriedwithluggage
Why consider outsourcing your organisation's social media management?
When you want to grow or when social media is eating up too much time: The size of your arts organisation is a key factor when considering your online strategy and whether you want to keep online communications internal or external. If you have a large company with many strands to your digital strategy, it may well need a number of people on the campaign at specific, busy times - for example, during the launch of a new show or after a big announcement. Alternatively, keeping up with the constant distraction of having to check all your social media platforms and responding in a timely way can be particularly difficult for a small team who are already maxed-out with work.
When you need to formalise the process: This brings us to the major drawback with regards to keeping social media in house. It’s on a par with your own website. Client and essential production work takes precedence every time over spending time representing yourself online. Social media gets relegated to the bottom of the pile for too long; it gets neglected. If you commit to a contract with external support providers, it raises the level of respect for the task. You are also committing to providing the credentials they need to do the job properly and on time - otherwise it’s your own money you're wasting.
When you need specialised knowledge and advice: Another benefit to outsourcing your social media is that you have a team of trained professionals at your disposal. From strategy, through to analysis of your analytics: it all needs to be considered and monitored if you are going to use social media in a business capacity. It can be hard to find a member of staff internally who has this expertise on top of their normal day job, just as it may be expensive to hire a full-time member of staff in possession of this range of skills. And, of course, it would have to be full-time - or even more than that - because, as we all know, social media is not a 9-5 activity.
Your voice: It's essential that your organisation’s online voice is consistent with your overall marketing strategy and identity. As long as you can spend some time with the people you will be entrusting with this (pretty big!) responsibility and you find people you click with and who ‘get you’, then running your social media externally can be a really practical and productive choice.
Sarah Morris (@iamburley) is Marketing Manager at Sequence, a creative digital agency. Sequence are currently seeking arts organisations to help trial their new social media management service; drop Sarah a line to find out more.
Giving your voice away is never a good idea
Arts organisations are currently trying to adapt to the socially networked media environment. One key issue for many is exactly what type of work should be outsourced. Asking a third party agency to speak on your behalf is a sure fire method of guaranteeing a failure to adapt in the long term.
Social media have the potential to transform not only marketing, but working practices, collaboration and the relationships between artists, audiences and organisations. It is communications on steroids conversations that are happening in real time, in public, in multiple media much more than simple outbound marketing messaging such as website content. It can host live customer service, facilitating collaborative working, new ways of working together, and even part of productions or shows.
One of the reasons social media has taken off is the usability of the platforms and the ease with which they can be learnt and used effectively by anyone. It’s easy for staff to use social platforms for networking effectively in their own role, and organisational voices to share insights and messages from across the team. Much harder for third party agency to fully understand your organisation, its politics, its creative philosophy and unique insights, and then conduct all of your communications on the social web. Much, much harder for an agency to match the creative potential that sits within arts organisations.
Outsourcing social media conversations makes little sense, and organisations succeeding with social understand this. They are enabling staff to engage with colleagues inside and outside the organisation and this new technical environment is changing the way that communications work happens within organisations, the role of communications professionals, and organisation’s relationships with the public.
Whether on a corporate or individual account, authenticity of voice is important, relationships are both personal and professional, and learning is something you have to do yourself. Outsourcing social media conversations is a little like paying someone to go to the gym for you, or represent you at meetings. The job may get done, but you don’t feel the benefit, and just delay the point at which you get involved with your networks.
Most organisations we work with are pressured for time to do social media communications regularly many have not properly assessed the demands of the work or indeed it’s value. But even the busiest chief executives and artistic directors are seeing it’s importance and set aside time for listening, responding, blogging and engaging with the people who matter to their organisation. It is partly a matter of priorities. Giving someone else the job will simply make it easier to forget about it and mistakenly believe that it’s being done.
It can be really useful to bring in external help to enable your organisation to work smarter with social media. When looking at strategic questions, it’s helpful to have people who understand the organisation and it’s art, know what’s possible on social platforms and can work with you to create a custom approach that ensures your activity on social media supports your goals.
It’s useful to bring in training that can support your strategy and help those who are unfamiliar or nervous about digital platforms to understand the potential benefits for their roles and become more effective atusing them. Organisations tell us that designing an approach to a campaign, production, show or event with experienced and knowledgeable people who understand their organisation is helpful. And some may need to bring people into the organisation to manage social media for a time limited campaign. Our clients value being able to set up meaningful metrics and interpret data and have regular conversations about their performance and priorities. Sometimes there is a demand to outsource the production of digital assets; infographics, videos, images and the like. And it can be useful to have people who can interpret the value of new and emerging platforms to the work you can do.
But handing your voice, your relationships and your learning over to a third party? The Cluetrain Manifesto reminds us that “the human voice is unmistakably genuine. It can't be faked”. If people start to outsource theirs, then the network itself would be at risk, with impersonators talking to imposters discussing mimics.
Your voice is your voice. Don’t hand it over to someone else.
Tom Beardshaw (@tombeardshaw) is a partner at Native HQ, a web and social media strategy agency.
Does your organisation outsource social media management, or would you consider it? Let us know in the comments below, or on Twitter.